Sunday, June 13, 2010

back to school

After a week of classes I can safely say that the Indian collegiate education system is rather different from the liberal arts format so common in the US. In India students select a concentration and from that concentration their entire class schedule is predetermined. You will take exactly the same courses as everyone else in your concentration and you will take only those classes that are part of your concentration. This is much like a trade or technical school in the US – following a specific set of courses and not choosing from a basket of options – only it is applied to every degree program; from philosophy to business administration.

My initial reaction to this system is that it is constricting – especially when dealing with higher education. (Part of the reason I dropped out of music school was because I was unable to study other things that interested me in detail.) However, since I’m pretty ok with my current course load and I’m only here for one semester the somewhat restrictive nature of the system is not prevalent.

At several levels, my class structure is such that I feel like I am back in high school. I am taking a prescribed set of classes, all of which are with the same group of people. I’m in class from 9am to 4pm Monday through Friday as the honors econ program translates to about 32 credit hours per semester. Even the room that I take all my classes in has kind of a high school vibe to it, with its outdated computer and heavily laminated, uncomfortable desks.

The classes, with the exception of two, are completely dominated by lectures and contain virtually no discussion. Assignments are to be turned in handwritten. Roll is taken at the beginning of each of my 6 classes. Prior to the day’s lecture, teachers will put random, specific students on the spot and verbally quiz them about the previous days' material (for points). For my part, I was 4 minutes late to a class (because I was talking with another professor about schools in the US) and once in the room was promptly kicked back out. If you aren’t there on time then you don’t get to participate in the class (there’s a school policy, didn’t you know?)

While I anticipate learning a lot and really solidifying my current knowledge it will be done in fashion that is, at best, unfamiliar and at worst draconian. What the system lacks in fostering creativity it makes up for through teaching a dogged work ethic.

Students here also find the work load intense; honors programs are a much more serious commitment than simply a regular degree. However everyone that I talk to fully intends to go to a grad school (they are generally aiming for big name schools in either the US or England) for at least a masters, if not a doctorate or two, in something lucrative. The common view is that this is the big investment and once you get into a good grad school everything else will fall into place. Veracity of that assumption aside, it certainly seems to be a powerful motivator for my peers. We’ll see if my own rather directionless motivation can keep up.

1 comment:

Unknown said...

I've often wondered what someone used to that 'draconian' system feels when thrown into our convoluted system of education (: