Thursday, July 8, 2010

stats man

This is an old post that’s been rattling but I’ve been putting off adding to the blog because I am, by and large, rather lazy.

This post is mostly me whining about bad teachers. Because even though I’m half away around the world, it still stands that people with degrees are not always good teachers.

The man who teaches statistics class is horribly petty – and that’s being nice. It took him 25 minutes to administer a 3 minutes, one question test. The reason for the delay was because the test simply had to be written out on plain, A4 paper. Lined paper or paper of any other size was simply not acceptable (for some undefined reason). So the class took 20 minutes trying to figure out how to get plain A4 sheets for everyone – even so far as trying to put together a class reserve of A4 paper in the event of such A4 emergencies. Never mind the obvious fact that the type of paper that the test is written on has absolutely no bearing on the veracity of the answer.

He also made a girl cry because she wouldn’t tell him who made a joke behind his back (mostly because she wasn’t involved in the joke/laughing process).

I am also really unsure about the actual material that he’s teaching. Now I base my judgments on the fact that I have taken a stats class before (in addition to them econometrics) and he is teaching things that, at least based on my education, range from being almost correct to completely unnecessary. An example of the conflict between my education and what he teaches is when the class learned a complex method to determine the mode of a highly skewed sample. While skewed samples are everywhere and determining mode is kinda important the difference is that my learnin’ dictates that if the sample is so highly skewed that the mode needs to be arithmetically determined then either:

• the classes that confine the data need to be reworked (so the data can be
manipulated with violating statsmath assumptions) or

• the data is too skewed and that means that useful statsmath can’t be executed

The point I’m trying to make is that, as far as I can tell, he is basically wasting everybody’s time all of the time. That and he has no interest in teaching the class how to use excel for stats – which is basically criminal.

He also taught us that the difference between a diagram and a graph is that graphs only appear on graph paper. And you thought those words were synonyms, didn’t you?

And this is where it gets difficult; I am completely incapable of determining which material he’s teaching that I’m unfamiliar with is actually relevant and which is totally bullshit. (See Greg Banazack) Looking at what my classmates are diligently learning (I guess it’s important for the reader to know that I am not required to take the stats class because I’ve already passed stats) there seems to be some important looking things. Now I don’t know what a quadratic mean is but I imagine it exists for some particular reason. But is it a relevant reason? A reason that maintains validity given the existence of Excel, Eviews and other such statistical computer programs? I simply do not know – and neither does anyone else in the class. And I wonder if Stats Man himself knows.

This is the crux of bad teaching. The most infuriating kind of teaching. Where the teacher presents information in such an unappealing way that there is no incentive beyond the course’s grade to learn. In this environment no one is going to really learn the material – they will just memorize so they can regurgitate later and then promptly forget it. So even if there is worthwhile information in the course it is buried under layers of seeming unimportance that the really important material is not learned. And everybody loses.

Which is why I am not retaking stats with the Stats Man.

No comments: